Strong Dissenting Opinion of Judge’s Ruling’

The Honorable Barry D. Brown

Cameron County Courthouse

RE: Docket #MJ-59301-CV-0000053-2014

Dear Judge Brown,

In regards to the court hearing on 1/7/2015, docket number referenced above, I am compelled to express my contention that your ruling in this matter was incorrect, and not just simply in your interpretation of the Home Improvement Consumer Protection Act (HICPA ), but more importantly, the message it sent the plaintiffs in the matter.  The HICPA is NOT ambiguous, subject to interpretation, or confusing.  It is not meant to be — the guidelines are clearly written for all to see, and hopefully abide.

 

Leave a Comment